Top 5 Accent Ideas For Kitchen Island Colors

The kitchen is the heart of the home (and the stomach), and the kitchen island is often the focal point of this important room. This is especially true at my home, where we have designated that area “Wine Island” due to it being our favorite place to indulge in happy hour. If you’re thinking about updating your kitchen island, one of the best ways to make a big impact is by changing the paint color. Whether you’re going for a bold statement or a subtle accent, there are plenty of popular and trending paint colors for kitchen cabinet islands. Please join in the discussion of our Top 5 Accent Ideas For Kitchen Island Colors.

Sherwin Williams Naval – Navy blue is a classic color that has been gaining popularity in recent years. This rich, deep hue is a great choice for kitchen islands because it pairs well with a variety of other colors and materials. Navy blue is also a great option for those who want to add a touch of sophistication to their kitchen. Or sports fans that enjoy teams from Pennsylvania, W. Virginia, Notre Dame, or Michigan.

Just Add Paint, only cabinets — Sherwin Williams Naval Island Accent with shaker doors and carpentry add-on, Just Add Paint

2. Sherwin Williams Repose Gray – This soft gray is a timeless and versatile color that pairs well with literally everything. It is a great choice for those who want a subtle yet stylish look. This neutral hue can work with a variety of decor styles, from traditional to modern. This is the safest choice on our list, and will give the least amount of “pop against white cabinets. But it is just enough color to set the island off as a stand alone accent. Also, apologies to Sherwin Williams Agreeable Gray, which was a close second neutral that almost made the list.

3. Sherwin Williams Evergreen Fog – This cool green is a bold and trendy color that is sure to make a statement. It was Sherwin Williams color to the year in 2022, and for good reason. This cooler tone is a great choice for those who want to add a pop of color to their kitchen island. It pairs well with brass or gold hardware and can work with a variety of other colors, including white, black, and gray.

House painting ideas, cabinets only — Sherwin Williams Evergreen Fog Kitchen Island Accent Color

4. Sherwin Williams Peppercorn – Peppercorn is a deep, dramatic gray that can add a touch of elegance to your kitchen. It pairs well with a variety of other colors and can work with a variety of decor styles. This color is a great choice for those who want a darker, more moody look. We have used Peppercorn at least a dozen times over the years. It is well balanced enough to work with creamy whites, bright whites, and everything in between.

Just Add Paint Cabinet Painters Refinishers. Cabinet Only — Recent Just Add Paint Kitchen project in Mechanicsburg. Sherwin Williams Peppercorn Island Accent.

5. Sherwin Williams French Roast, Turkish Coffee, And Espresso. We could have simply called this section “Dark Brown”, but that would have been far less fun. I would dare to say that Sherwin Williams got it right and all of these colors are true to name. So why not go with the coffee theme? We see less browns than we used to due to gray dominating the charts for the last several years. HOWEVER, if you have tan walls or tan/warmer undertones in your tile, brown may be the way to go. I am putting these 3 colors side by side to compare below. If you choose to go brown on your island, I strongly suggest using the company https://samplize.com . We have used this company for color samples over and over and they never disappoint. Sticky-backed color cards usually arrive in 2-3 day so you can compare undertones in natural lighting.

Kitchen island accent colors — Sherwin Williams French Roast

Cabinets only Mechanicsburg — Sherwin Williams French Roast

Added Bonus Accent Kitchen Island Colors:

We didn’t want to finish this blog without giving Benjamin Moore some love because they have an awesome color book. Sherwin Williams is more accessible to us in Mechanicsburg, but great accent colors can come from many sources. Here are a few we have used and love.

Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter – Revere Pewter is at the top of the warm gray food chain neutrals, and looks lovely with whites. It is beloved by homeowners and designers alike. It is a light-medium gray, and had some beige in it. This makes is more super versatile, so the color works well with both traditional and contemporary styles. Benjamin Moore nailed it on this one.

Shaker replacement cabinet door by Just Add Paint. Cabinets only — Color Sample Benjamin Moore Revere Pewter shaker style door for Kitchen Island Accents

2. Benjamin Moore Kendall Charcoal – Kendall Charcoal is an awesome kitchen island accent color. It’s a rich and deep gray that works well with both warm and cool on the main cabinets. This color is an excellent choice for those who want a different deep gray to compare/contrast with Peppercorn.

Cabinets only, just add paint, kitchen island accent — Sherwin Williams Peppercorn

cabinets only, kitchen cabinets, just add paint — Sherwin Williams Peppercorn

When choosing a paint color for your kitchen island, it’s important to consider the overall look and feel of your kitchen. Think about the colors and materials you already have in the space and choose a color that will complement them. Lighter and medium bodied colors will provide a subtle accent, and darker colors can be dramatic or just help ground the room. Whether you go bold or stick with a more classic look, updating the paint color of your kitchen island is a great way to refresh your kitchen and add value to your home. If you need help with selecting a color, just ask us! We love to talk shop, and have painted several hundred sets of cabinets to help us make an educated guess on what you are looking for.